Skip to main content

Behind the crypto hype is an ideology of social change

 

For some, promoting cryptocurrencies is political activism. Vasil Dimitrov/E+ via Getty Images
Rick Wash, Michigan State University

Ads for blockchain, NFTs and cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin seem to be everywhere. Crypto technologies are being promoted as a replacement for banks; a new way to buy art; the next big investment opportunity, and an essential part of the metaverse.

To many, these technologies are confusing or risky. But enthusiasts ardently promote them.

As a cybersecurity and social media researcher, I’ve found that behind the hype is an ideology about social change: Hardcore enthusiasts argue that crypto will get people to trust in technology rather than government, which they see as inherently untrustworthy. This ideology leads people to encourage its use while downplaying its risks.

The true believers

My colleagues and I studied almost three months of discussions on Reddit forums about cryptocurrencies to try to understand how people talk about crypto and Bitcoin. The loudest voices on the forum were a group of crypto enthusiasts who called themselves “True Bitcoiners.” Unlike technology enthusiasts or crypto marketers, “true bitcoiners” didn’t talk about technology, or about their own use of crypto. Instead, they talked about trust and corruption.

These crypto enthusiasts often cite examples of what they see as government corruption and corporate corruption. They recognize that society depends on governments and corporations setting and enforcing rules, and they complain that people are stuck with these “corrupt” institutions. Corruption, they say, is an inevitable flaw in humanity and leads to trying to control and mistreat others.

The enthusiasts see Bitcoin, blockchain and other crypto technologies as providing an alternative to the corruption. They argue that these new technologies are “trustless” and don’t depend on institutions. You can buy and sell things using bitcoin without checking with a bank or using government-issued cash.

Blockchain, the technology underlying cryptocurrencies, keeps records of ownership and transactions without requiring trust in anyone or any institution.

These two beliefs – that governments are corrupt and that crypto avoids that corruption – are common among the crypto enthusiasts we studied. But enthusiasts go one step further. They seek change. They want to change who has power and who doesn’t.

They argue that crypto is how that change will happen. For crypto enthusiasts, using crypto isn’t just a way to buy and sell things. By using crypto technologies, they argue, society will become less dependent on governments and corporations. That is, using crypto – and getting as many people as possible to use it as much as possible – is a way to change the world and take power away from governments.

Pushing an ideology

These beliefs about who should and should not have power in society embody an ideology. An important part of the crypto ideology is that this change can’t happen unless people use crypto. The technology and the ideology are tied together.

For many of these enthusiasts, recommending crypto to other people is not just a technology recommendation. To them, buying and selling crypto is a form of political and social activism. They argue that buying crypto will remove corruption and change society to trust technology over government.

This ideology is a more extreme version of technolibertarianism, which seeks to replace government with technology. Like technolibertarians, true bitcoiners want technology to control society. But they focus on financial and economic control more than civil liberties. And because promoting crypto is part of this ideology, crypto has often been compared with a religion.

Crypto dangers

An important aspect of any ideology is the way it emphasizes some dangers and downplays others. True bitcoiners emphasize the problems with government corruption. But they downplay the financial risks of crypto. The price of Bitcoin fluctuates wildly, and many people have lost money buying crypto. Crypto wallets are difficult to understand and use, and fraudulent transactions are difficult to reverse.

Crypto enthusiasts frequently downplay the technology’s risks to people and society. They also dismiss the valuable role that governments and corporations play in protecting people’s money, providing insurance for bank accounts and returning money that’s been stolen.

Beliefs in crypto’s ability to create social change are also overstated. Crypto technologies don’t necessarily eliminate corporations or avoid government control. There are private, corporate blockchains and many government regulations about cryptocurrencies. As I see it, simply using the technology doesn’t necessarily lead to the social change these enthusiasts seek.

[Science, politics, religion or just plain interesting articles: Check out The Conversation’s weekly newsletters.]The Conversation

Rick Wash, Associate Professor of Information Science and Cybersecurity, Michigan State University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Forex Forecasting: How to Avoid the Traps and Become a Successful Trader

                                          Image Source: Pexels Forex is a dynamic market and its pitfalls are many. It is a fast-paced, ever-changing market that poses a challenge to even the most seasoned traders. However, the rewards are great for those who persevere. Forex is one of the most profitable and dynamic markets because of its 24-hour trading flexibility, price volatility and its ability to quickly respond to market changes. This article will explore the pitfalls traders can encounter and how to avoid them. It will also teach you how to become a successful forex trader and how to eliminate the frustrations of trading. What is Forex? In simple terms, forex is the foreign exchange market, which tracks the buying and selling of currencies around the world. It is an open marketplace where currencies can be bought and sold to determine their relative value. The main forex market is the interbank market where banks bring together buyers and sellers of foreign currency with the

Benefits of Essential Oils and How to Choose the Ones You Want to Use

  Humans have relied on essential oils for centuries to meet a wide range of needs. Others are toning, calming, grounding, energizing, warming, and renewing. Essential oils can do all of these things. You can use essential oils in the most natural way possible because there are so many different kinds to choose from. This article will explain the benefits of essential oils and how to choose the ones you want to use. Some of the most commonly used oils and how to use them are listed here. Plants' concentrated essences are known as essential oils. Phytochemicals, which are derived from various plant parts, are chemicals that have medicinal properties and are found in phytochemicals. One pound of essential oil can be made from a pound of lavender flowers, five pounds of rose petals, and 5,000 pounds of lemon balm. That's a significant sum of money! The fact that they smell great isn't the only reason they're so popular. Aromatherapy isn't the only use for essential oi

Can you truly own anything in the metaverse? A law professor explains how blockchains and NFTs don’t protect virtual property

João Marinotti , Indiana University In 2021, an investment firm bought 2,000 acres of real estate for about US$4 million. Normally this would not make headlines, but in this case the land was virtual. It existed only in a metaverse platform called The Sandbox . By buying 792 non-fungible tokens on the Ethereum blockchain , the firm then owned the equivalent of 1,200 city blocks. But did it? It turns out that legal ownership in the metaverse is not that simple. The prevailing but legally problematic narrative among crypto enthusiasts is that NFTs allow true ownership of digital items in the metaverse for two reasons: decentralization and interoperability. These two technological features have led some to claim that tokens provide indisputable proof of ownership , which can be used across various metaverse apps, environments and games. Because of this decentralization, some also claim that buying and selling virtual items can be done on the blockchain itself for whatever price y

Who is trading in the foreign exchange market?

Trading currencies between countries, as well as deciding when to invest in currencies, is what forex trading is all about. For example, foreign exchange is traded between countries through a broker or financial institution. Foreign exchange trading, like stock trading, has become a popular pastime for many people. Banks, governments and brokers are the primary players in the market while retail traders are known as bystanders. The forex market fluctuates on a daily basis due to changes in the broader financial market. Every day, millions of dollars are exchanged between a number of large countries, and this includes some trade between smaller countries as well. Interbank transactions are the most common in the foreign exchange market, according to research conducted over the years. About half of all transactions in the foreign exchange market are handled by banks. Since the banks are using this method to make money for shareholders and their own business advancement, you know that th